Michael Haneke’s provocative adaptation of Elfriede Jelinek’s harrowing novel (first screened at the Cannes Film Festival in May 2001) is difficult to digest, but worthy of consumption. Detachment and dependence ferment in THE PIANO TEACHER’s labyrinth of trauma and loneliness.
Erika Kohut (Isabelle Huppert) is a middle-aged piano teacher trapped in an enmeshed relationship with her dictatorial mother (Annie Girardot). Longing for connection and autonomy, she pursues the advances of a young student (Benoît Magimel), which stirs up suppressed and unconventional fixations for her.
The dysfunctional dynamic between Erika and her mother sets a deviant tone from the outset. Erika’s outfit blends into the beige tones of their apartment, symbolising her dull and lifeless existence. She fades into the background like a piece of furniture, closer in essence to an object than a human. Erika’s mother tries to control every aspect of her life.
The claustrophobic feel of the dreary apartment, in contrast to Haneke’s long takes of Erika’s withdrawn interactions with the outside world and its inhabitants, magnifies the oppressed mood of Jelinek’s novel. Erika is forced to share a bed with her mother, blurring the line between maternal and incestuous, the mother and the lover; both devoid of compassion.
THE PIANO TEACHER’s transposition from Jelinek’s literary dissection to Haneke’s enigmatic canvas transforms the aesthete into a voyeur, a fly on the wall overlooking the tangled web of codependency and self-destruction.
“Haneke’s lens lurks discreetly, a stylistic nod to the mental intrusions that quietly consume Erika. He avoids sensationalist cuts to the domestic violence and self-mutilation that become the heartbeat of the home.”
Like her mother, Erika seems to take pleasure in power. She belittles and torments her students. She also shares distinct similarities with her victims, captured in both confronting and tender moments by Haneke, shedding the thin veil between depravity and repression.
The antithesis of the prude and pervert archetype in Haneke’s composition unravels the psychosexual intricacies within Erika’s fragmented identity. She condemns the lustful parts of others, yet frequents sex shops in the evenings. Erika exists within two incompatible worlds, informed and distorted by her mother’s infantilisation of her.
“Isabelle Huppert’s gut-punching performance solidifies THE PIANO TEACHER as one of modern cinema’s most profound, painful, and transcendental films.”
Desperate to share her hidden world, Erika becomes intimately involved with prospective student, Walter Klemmer: a union she hopes will bring understanding, liberation, and escape. But the relationship quickly drifts into a familiar battle for control and sinks abruptly into darker desires. Erika and Walter possess different ideals of love; both resolutely wish to possess the other. Walter’s character unmasks in the shadows of Haneke’s existential investigation—which omits more than it includes—revealing Erika’s detachment from the subtleties of misogyny within society’s androcentrism of female sexuality.
Haneke’s lens lurks discreetly, a stylistic nod to the mental intrusions that quietly consume Erika. He avoids sensationalist cuts to the domestic violence and self-mutilation that become the heartbeat of the home. Haneke distances the camera from surface wounds, and instead pushes it towards piercing close-ups of Erika. Her fragility is concealed within Huppert’s constrained expressions, which soon peel away to the agony underneath; real scars lie deeply, inaccessibly within.
Isabelle Huppert’s gut-punching performance solidifies THE PIANO TEACHER as one of modern cinema’s most profound, painful, and transcendental films. Huppert’s beautifully shattering portrayal of an abused woman’s descent into maladaptive masochism will linger in the minds of viewers indefinitely.
‘TAKE TWO’ is a new series celebrating the legacy of enduring cinema, where our writers revisit these films to express what makes them special and remarkable to them today.